-
wsfic icfuture howtoproceed 2
ICFUTURE
ENGLISH
I. background
Political culture of the Forum: to recover it from different documents - and confirm if it is implement or not.
Membership - check who they are and are willing to participate
II: uprising of the problematic
Political questions to clarify:
What is the WSF about?
What is the IC about? Is it just a matter of organizing social movements? Of bringing them together? Is it about proposing alternatives to a capitalist and neoliberal world order? Is it about searching for convergence between people and movements? Is it about creating ‘civil society’ next to but separate from the political world? (FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan
Or is encouraging the participation of civil society in the processes of change, as a political actor? Bringing together those who believe that another world is possible and contribute to the struggle for this other world? An instrument of the subject of transformative action (social movements and social organizations - that seek to overcome capitalism?) ChicoLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en (Chico)
Many of these answers are not alternatives to neoliberalism. That is why the importance of responding to these, or others, to outline more clearly the content of the Forum as event-space- alternative instance
Questions about the role of the IC
IC which was the initial role of the CI?-(internationalist perspective? promote the expansion of the process? To concrete it’s functioning through commissions and working groups? one imporant IC role is to facilitate wsf process about "events" and "process initiatives" PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3
Which is the interest of organizations participating in the process of the CI? ChicoLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en
III. Balance of the current moment
Positive meanings of the process (what we have accumulate)
(In documents of Chico. Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan , the first episode of PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3 ) see overviewLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home Francine, the first part of the protocol # 1 of Pierre)
FSM basically as horizontal process in its original orientation.
current rules - which of them correspond to a possible good performance, which of them must be disposed
decisions by consensus - to keep the union, with the wealth of diverse views
CI as a dimension of "governance" or "self-government"?
Limitations – what we did wrong and why
(To be found in documents of FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan ,, second part of the # episode 1 of PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3 , Francine, second part f the Protocol # 1 of Pierre, critics posed by JasonLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-7 ….)see overviewLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home
More general limitations
CI as space open to observers - hinder the fluidity in the meetings
new memberships that have no response to their requests
organizations that have already left some time ago the CI and still are there
Burocratic organizations that send delegates to the IC and take decisions for the ones they are not prepared.
More organizative limitations
Process of decision-making-as prevent informal decisions and at the same time ensure flexibility in the decisions? mireilleLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-5 FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan
Mechanisms of transparency
decentralization processes some proposals of future performance
lack of stimulation of and discusion about wsf process facilitation work in IC - Pierre proposal of review protocol Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3/#_Toc334095573
More political dimensions
Findings:
lack of strategic vision – How can we build it
Lack of impact and political success in the last period of the WSF. FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan
Reviews
Specification of the limits of Open Space to ensure a safe space.
To go from organizational matters to political discussion (role of the Strategic Commission or similar instances)
Lack of policy discussion on major global dynamics today, necessary to redynamise (give more dynamism) the CI with new memberships – attracting “organic” intellectuals, addressing new expressions of neo-liberalism as green economy, etc.
clear mechanisms to extend the FSM-IC to other movements actors stimulate dicussion about facilitaiton tasks in IC update a plan about what is done Pierre Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3/#_Toc334095573 actorss
define the previous tasks thatmembers of the CI must be carried out before the meetings of the CI (FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan , RitaLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-6/#_Toc335819971 , Pierre( review group Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3/#_Toc334095573 ) (Francine, Rita)
Some proposals for change
(To be found in documents-proposals of SaraLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-4 , RitaLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-6/#_Toc335819971 , and Giuseppe, FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan and Pierre review protocol (episode 2)Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3/#_Toc334095573 ) see overviewLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home http://openfsm.net/projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-homeLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home
To imagine a new possible arquitectura for WSF-IC. (i-e a guding principles document like Guiding principles for event organizing Link: /projects/ic-methodology/metcom-pgoex ?) Reviewing the work done in IC As a facilitating body of wsf process? PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3/#_Toc334095573 (Guiding principles?)
As a parliamentary assembly of alterglobalización movement?
There is a need to open this discussion to Tunez team for WSF 2013.
Gina
___________________________________________________________________________________________
Esquema de trabajo
I. Antecedentes
Cultura política del foro: recuperarla desde los diferentes documentos – y confirmar su implementación,o no.
Membresía- chequear quienes son y como están dispuestos a participar
II: Levantamiento de la problemática
Las preguntas políticas a clarificar:
Cual es el significado del Foro hoy? Cual es el rol del CI hoy? El FSM es espacio para organizar movimientos sociales? para hacerlos confluir? Es para proponer alternativas al orden neoliberal global? Es buscar la convergencia entre personas y movimientos? Es acerca de crear sociedad civil en relación pero autónoma del mundo político? (FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan (Francine) O es impulsar la participación de la sociedad civil en los procesos de cambio, como un actor político?Reunir a quienes creen que otro mundo es posible y contribuir a aumentar la lucha por ese otro mundo?Un instrumento del sujeto de acción transformadora (movimientos sociales y organizaciones sociales- que buscan superar el capitalismo? ChicoLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en (Chico)
Varios de estas posibles respuestas no son alternativas al neoliberalismo. De allí la importancia de respondera estas, u otras, para perfilar mas claramente el contenido del Foro como espacio-evento-instancia alternativa
Las preguntas sobre el roldel CI
Cual fue el rol inicial del CI? – ( perspectiva internacionalista?, promoverla expansión del proceso. Concretar el funcionamiento a través de comisiones) un papel importante de CI es faclitar el proceso fsm sobre evntos y iniciativasde processo PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es
Cual es el interés de las organizaciones de participar en el proceso del CI? ChicoLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en
III.Balance del momento actual
1. Significaciones positivas del proceso: que hemos acumulado
(En documentos de Chico, Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-1-en (PT) en parte de FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan , Francine, en la primera parte de episodio 1 de PierreLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es )(ES)http://openfsm.net/projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home
FSM proceso básicamente horizontal en su orientación inicial
Reglas actuales - cuales corresponden a un posible buen funcionamiento, cuales deben ser desechadas:
Decisiones por consenso – para que la unión se mantenga, con la riqueza de diversas opiniones
CI como dimensión de “gobernabilidad” o de “autogobierno”?
2. Dimensiones a revisar
Limitaciones- que se hizo mal y porque
(A ser rastreados en FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan , Francine, en evaluaciones, en segunda parte de episodio 1 de Pierre ES,Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es documento de Pierre, en criticas de Jason Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-7 EN….)ver la vista general ENLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home …)
Generales
CI como espacio abierto a observadores- dificultan la fluidez en las reuniones
Nuevas membresías que no tienen respuesta a sus solicitudes
Organizaciones que ya han abandonado hace un tiempo el CI
Organizaciones burocráticas que envían delegados-as al CItomando decisiones para las que no están preparadas.
Dimensiones más organizativas
Proceso de toma de decisiones.- como evitar las decisiones informales y al mismo tiempo asegurar agilidad en las decisiones? mireilleLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-5 FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan
Procesos de descentralización
Mecanismos de transparencia
Revista de la agenda de facilitacion del processo en el CI Pierre ESLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es
Dimensiones más políticas
Constataciones:
falta de visión estratégica- cómo la construimos
falta de impacto y éxito político en el ultimo periodo del WSF. FrancineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan algunas preguntas en el agenda del ci mireilleLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-5
Revisiones
la especificación de los limites del Open Space para garantizar un espacio seguro-
el pasar de asuntos organizativos a discusión política(rol de la comisión de Estrategias o instancia similar)
Falta de discusión política sobre las grandes dinámicas globales hoy, necesarias para redinamizar el CI con nueva membresías- atraer a intelectuales “orgánicos”, abordar las nuevas expresiones del neoliberalismo como Economía verde, etc.
Claros mecanismos para ampliar el FSM-CI a otros movimientos /actores-as
estimular discusion y tareas de facilitacion del proceso fsm - protocol de revision de tareas de facilitacion Pierre
Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es
Definir las tareas previas que los –las integrantes del CI tienen que realizar antes de las reuniones del CI (francineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan/#_Toc335855572 , RitaLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-6/#_Toc335819971 ,Pierre "grupo revista" ESLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es ) (Francine, Rita)
Algunas propuestasde funcionamiento futuro
(En documentos de SaraLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-4 , RitaLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-6/#_Toc335819971 ,, Giuseppe, francineLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-2-plan/#_Toc335855572 Sara, Rita, Giuseppe, y de Pierre (episodio 2- protocolo de revision)Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es/#_Toc334541568 ) ver la vista general ENLink: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home http://openfsm.net/projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuture-home
Imaginar arquitectura possible del WSF-IC – principios guias (o sea un documento como principles guia para organizar eventos Link: /projects/ic-methodology/metcom-pgoex ?)
como una asamblea parlamentaria del movimiento alterglobalización?
Revisando el trabajo hecho en el CI como entidad de facilitacion del proceso fsmPierre Link: /projects/wsfic_fsmci/wsfic-icfuturecontribution-3-es/#_Toc334541568
Es importante hacer la discusión con los organizadores de Túnez
Gina